When walking away is the right call: Spielberg, Porgy and Bess, and knowing your lane

By Todd Max Carey · 2026-08-17

Steven Spielberg spent years developing a remake of Porgy and Bess. The studio was behind him. The budget was there. A-list names were interested. Then, in 2020, he shelved it without ceremony. Not because of COVID logistics, not because of a scheduling clash. After extensive consultation he had concluded that he was not the right person to direct it. There was no press release dressing it up as “creative differences.” He made the decision and he honoured it.

That is rarer than it should be. The film industry runs on momentum and on ego. Once a project carries studio approval and financing, stepping away reads as failure. Directors are supposed to wrestle productions into existence, to beat every obstacle through force of will. Spielberg had already shown he could resist that pressure on Lincoln, where he cast actual historians as advisors and reshaped dialogue around what they told him. Porgy and Bess asked something harder of him: to accept the limits of consultation itself. You can hire the experts. You can listen with real care. You may still not be the right storyteller for this particular story.

I raise this because it reaches well beyond one unmade film. I work with productions across Europe and North America, and in five years the conversation around cultural sensitivity has shifted dramatically. Ten years ago the question in the room was: “Can we afford a consultant?” Now it is: “Are we the right team for this project at all?” That second question makes people profoundly uncomfortable, especially when they have already sunk months into development. It is also the only question that genuinely protects the story and the production together.

I understand the urge to push on regardless. Securing funding is no small thing. The crew is ready. The team is capable of technical excellence. Surely good intentions plus rigorous research can close whatever gap remains. This is exactly where productions run aground. Cultural sensitivity is not a problem you solve through diligence alone, and it is not a checklist where enough effort guarantees authenticity. Some stories demand a lived proximity to the material, and no amount of preparation reproduces that.

I have sat in pre-production meetings where the producer announces, “We’ve hired a cultural consultant from the community we’re depicting,” as though that inoculates the project. The consultant is there to advise. They are not there to carry the whole weight of authenticity while a disconnected creative team keeps making the final calls. If the director cannot see why a scene feels extractive rather than exploratory, if the writer keeps slipping back into an outside-looking-in frame, then consultation becomes a fig leaf. The consultant knows it. The crew senses it. The audience will certainly clock it.

Spielberg’s decision models something different: consultation that actually changes the shape of the project, up to and including whether the project should exist. By most accounts he did not simply hear out Black creative voices on Porgy and Bess. He absorbed what they said about who should helm a story so deeply embedded in Black American experience, one with a fraught performance history behind it. And his conclusion was: not me, not now, maybe never. I do not read that as defeatism. I read it as creative maturity.

The counterargument is familiar. If only directors from a given background may tell those stories, does that not ghettoise both the storytellers and the material? There is a version of cultural gatekeeping that is corrosive, yes. We are nowhere near that problem. The dominant pattern in the industry is still outsider perspectives shaping insider stories, with actual community members hired into subordinate roles, if they are hired at all. We are still working through decades of extraction dressed up as appreciation. The pendulum has not swung too far. It has barely moved.

What the work requires is discernment about what “your lane” actually means. It is not about rigid demographic boxes. It is about an honest reckoning with your relationship to the material. Can you reach the emotional core without flattening it into metaphor? Are you drawn to the story’s specificity, or only to its aesthetic? If your main reference points are other films rather than lived knowledge, treat that as a warning sign. None of this means you cannot tell stories outside your own experience. It means you must examine why this story, and whether your distance from it will serve or diminish what makes it vital.

In documentary, where I started before moving into consulting, this gets complicated. Documentary assumes a degree of outsider perspective. You observe; you do not inhabit. Even so, proximity matters. I have turned down documentary projects where I knew my presence would shift the dynamic in ways that would undermine the story. Not because I could not technically shoot it, but because someone else’s relationship to the subjects would produce something more true. That calculus is professional, not personal.

Key Takeaways:

  1. Cultural consultation can’t fix a fundamental mismatch between storyteller and story. It can only help you recognise that the mismatch exists.

  2. Walking away from a developed project isn’t admitting defeat; it’s exercising creative judgment about what serves the story better than your involvement.

  3. “Staying in your lane” isn’t about demographic boxes. It’s about honest assessment of whether your proximity to the material serves or diminishes its core truth.

The projects that never get made rarely appear in career retrospectives. Spielberg will be remembered for the films he directed, not the one he stepped back from. Yet that decision, quiet and unglamorous and probably agonised over, may teach more than another entry in his filmography. The real achievement is not proving you can tell any story. It is knowing which stories need you to step aside so someone else can tell them properly. That kind of restraint looks like weakness right up until you recognise it as strength.


Todd Max Carey, Seven Journeys