When public scrutiny becomes a production concern: protecting performers beyond the set

By Todd Max Carey · 2026-10-01

The message arrived in pre-production. A lead performer had pulled away from social media altogether after sustained online criticism of her personal life, and the director wanted to know whether that changed how we would run the set. It did. Not in the way anyone around the table expected.

Ariana Grande stepped back from public visibility this past month while filming Wicked, and her decision names something most production teams still haven’t: the wall between on-set safety and off-set exposure has grown very thin. A performer who walks onto set carrying the weight of public dissection, the relationship commentary, the body commentary, the second-guessing of her career, does not leave it in the trailer. It shapes presence. It shapes availability. It shapes the quality of the vulnerable work we are asking her to deliver.

Sensitivity consulting, as traditionally practised, concerns itself with the production bubble. We map power dynamics. We design consent protocols for intimate scenes. We make sure cultural consultants are in the room when representation is at stake. All of that assumes the set exists on its own. It no longer does. Every performer now carries a second workplace in their pocket, one with no HR department, no union protections and no closing time.

The pressure itself is old. What has changed is its speed and its volume. A performer can shoot a demanding emotional scene in the morning, break for lunch, and open their phone to find hundreds of strangers arguing over whether they deserve their role, their partner, their body, their choices. Two hours later they are expected back on set, reaching for the same openness they brought that morning. We have built elaborate systems for physical safety and contractual consent. We still behave as if the digital dimension stops at the edge of the set.

This is not about coddling anyone. Psychological bandwidth is finite. When we cast someone in a role that demands sustained emotional availability or physical exposure, we are quietly asking them to save their resilience for the work. If that resilience is being spent on coordinated online campaigns or tabloid speculation, we are not getting the performance we hired. Worse, we are extracting labour under conditions our duty of care never accounted for.

I have started bringing digital boundary planning into pre-production conversations, particularly on projects involving intimacy work, cultural representation, or first-time performers stepping into high-profile roles. Nobody is being told how to run their social media. The point is to make room to talk about what sustainable engagement looks like during the shoot, what support the performer has outside our set, and whether the schedule leaves recovery time for the weeks when public attention spikes.

Some of this is practical: working with publicists so the performer is not fielding interview requests during the heaviest shooting weeks. Some is relational: making sure the performer knows which members of the production team are available for off-set check-ins when a pile-on starts eating into their capacity. Some is contractual: asking whether certain promotional obligations should be pushed back if personal circumstances make public visibility untenable.

The European productions I work with tend to start from stronger protections. Labour law limits shooting hours. Union standards require access to psychological support. Even here, though, we are late in folding digital realities into wellbeing frameworks. North American productions usually have far better publicity machinery and weaker labour protections, which produces a different sort of vulnerability. Neither system was built for a world in which performers are judged in real time on their private lives while being expected to deliver their most exposed professional work.

Grande’s withdrawal matters because it makes visible what many performers go through in silence: the calculation that protecting their ability to work means retreating from the very visibility that is supposed to serve their career. When someone with her standing, her resources and her negotiating power decides that public engagement cannot coexist with the work, production teams ought to ask what we expect of performers with less bargaining power, fewer resources and exactly the same pressures.

“This comes with the job” ignores how much the job has changed. Twenty years ago a performer could do the work, meet their contractual press obligations, and largely set the terms of their own public presence. Those terms are now set by algorithms amplifying the most inflammatory takes, by strangers who feel entitled to forensic readings of someone’s relationships, by a publicity machine that rewards speed over accuracy. Calling that the price of the career is simply a way of saying we will not adjust our practices to conditions we already know are unsustainable.

Three Key Takeaways:

  1. Build digital boundary conversations into pre-production for any role that requires sustained emotional or physical vulnerability. Treat them as scaffolding for sustainable performance, not as oversight.

  2. Work with publicists and agents to identify high-pressure periods where promotional obligations could collide with a performer’s capacity for demanding work, and build flexibility into the schedule.

  3. Train HODs and key crew to notice when off-set pressure is draining on-set capacity, and open non-punitive channels through which performers can ask for adjusted timelines or extra support.

We cannot insulate performers from public attention, and we should not try to manage how they handle their own visibility. What we can do is stop pretending that what happens off-set stays off-set, and start building production frameworks that take in the whole set of conditions performers are working within. The sensitivity work does not stop at the set boundary. It starts with admitting the boundary is gone.


Todd Max Carey, Seven Journeys